Return to CreateDebate.comacebertrand • Join this debate community

Bertrand's ACE Debate


Debate Info

63
62
Yes, raise the driving age. No, don't raise driving age
Debate Score:125
Arguments:95
Total Votes:159
Ended:01/24/14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, raise the driving age. (41)
 
 No, don't raise driving age (52)

Debate Creator

mbertrand(62) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Should the driving age be raised?

Yes, raise the driving age.

Side Score: 63
Winning Side!
VS.

No, don't raise driving age

Side Score: 62
2 points

I believe the driving age should be raised because sixteen year old's are simply not responsible enough. If they start at a older age, they will be more cautious and responsible on the road.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19kremter(16) Disputed
0 points

If a teenager doesn't have their own car/license they will most likely not have a job.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
1 point

Along to not having a job, They wont have money to support themselves, pay for things or help with anything they or their family needs. This will cause some economy problems with money expenses and funds.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19kkringle(8) Disputed
0 points

You may say that they are more responsible, but actually, driving accidents are not prone to age. They are prone to inexperience. So, by raising the driving age, you are taking the experience they could get at age 16 and moving it to an older age. Causing more death as 18 years old instead of 16 years old.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19blom Disputed
0 points

I disagree lots of teens are ready for the responsibility to get behind the wheel and the some that don't take it seriously that's there problem why have the responsible people wait for the people who aren't ready.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
2 points

Between 1995- 2004 there were 30,917 fatalities in accidents involving 15-17 year old's. 1/3 of the deaths are the teenage drivers.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19esanders(26) Disputed
1 point

According to John M. Crisp, most accidents are caused by inexperience, not age. If you raise the driving age we will still have inexperienced drivers, we just have to make sure are drivers are experienced and responsible.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19asiebers(15) Disputed
2 points

When you are older, you are wiser, and that makes you more mature. When you have to wait to get your license, you gain more maturity.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19kkringle(8) Disputed
1 point

So raising the driving age would NOT prevent that. It would delay the age. Just as many people would die. Just at a different age. The teens only need more experience. If you really wanted to prevent the death rates, start drivers ed at a younger age. And still have teens get their license at age 16.

Source: A. J. Rox

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19kremter(16) Disputed
0 points

It doesn't matter about the age, they get in the accidents because they were either not being careful, or they don't have enough experience.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19asiebers(15) Disputed
1 point

When they are older, they will be more cautious because they can get in more trouble with the law.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
2 points

Raising the driving age would help everyone. With our technology advancing, we are getting more and more safer cars. But having safer cars doesn't make drivers safer. In fact, it may make drivers more reckless because they think having a safer car will save them when they are being careless.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19esanders(26) Disputed
1 point

According to Alex Koroknay-Palicz, raising the driving age isn't going to help irresponsible drivers. Speeding will still be a problem, and there will be more drunk drivers and running red lights.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19tweinzetl(3) Disputed
2 points

But yet when people start getting older an less stupid they wont be running red lights. Like teens when there with friends they will be like I dare you to run a red light and knowing some teens they would do it

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19asiebers(15) Disputed
1 point

Yes, but when they are older, they will have more consequences with the law.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
2 points

Yes I think you should raise the driving age because of death. In nineteen ninety five to two thousand four there were thirty thousand nine hundred seventeen death of teens ages fifteen to seventeen. On December twenty ninth in two thousand five, four teenage boys went out for a late night drive. Just a normal little drive can hurt anyone right? Well, the car lost control and hit seven things. Two of the boys sixteen and seventeen then the driver who was sixteen died. This was only six days away from Christmas. Imagine never having another Christmas. For my second reason is other countries have a higher driving age. The United States Of America has the highest death ratio of teens dying in car crashes. In the USA there is 15.5 teen deaths in every hundred thousand teens driving. But that doesn't seem like a lot but as the years come by it gets higher and higher. In Germany its 9.8 teen deaths in every hundred thousand teen motorcycle deaths. And for my last reason is... If kids can't have guns smoke or do drugs why can they drive. Imagine four pot head teens doing some drugs. They get hungry and they want to go get some food. So they take there car. Driving when they were high. They will be seeing things they see a green light when its actually a red light and they hit a couple of kids walking across the road. Imagine having that guilt for the rest of your life. Cars are just as deadly as weapon. So you think its okay for teens to drive but no its not cars are just as deadly as weapons

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19kkringle(8) Disputed
0 points

Yes, many people die. But, by raising the driving age, you are not preventing death. you are only delaying when they die. And you might also say that peoples brains are more developed at age 18, but a human brain is actually NOT developed at age 18. It IS developed at age 21. So if you wanted to raise it to 21, when your brain is fully developed, you could. With that, raising to age 21 would cause countless problems with school education and transportation as adults.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19asiebers(15) Disputed
1 point

You make a good point, but when you are first born, you are an infant. Look at your self now. You've grown. Your brain will keep growing more at 18. It will have grown since you have been 16 right?

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
2 points

We should raise the driving age because kids are not ready to be behind the wheel. Kids might not have the right education or common sense to drive. This could lead so many deaths, just because of one small stupid mistake.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
2 points

Teenagers aren't the only ones that make small stupid mistakes though. Raising the driving age isn't going to solve other road problems like highway safety, and drunk drivers.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19asiebers(15) Disputed
1 point

But it's mostly teenagers that do. Adults can get in more trouble with the law.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19tstumpf(16) Disputed
1 point

Yes, but it will solve one of the biggest problems. It will solve some of the drunk drivers, and some of the highway safety.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19kremter(16) Disputed
1 point

kids just need to get a chance behind the wheel, once they get enough experience they will be fine behind the wheel.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
2 points

Yes I think the driving age should be raised because, when teenagers are young they attend to be cool and try new things well 77 percent of people in the world who get in car related accidents are people who Go fast, Try to be cool and text, Impressing somebody with what they think are smarts, And just try to do something and let go of the wheel. Alex-Koroknay-Palicz, said to a reporter that its not the car or what going on, its the inexperience that causes it not the other things around it. Teenager's under the age of 18 are legally forced to stop driving at around 10:30-4:00 in the morning, If people where to make the time start earlier it would reduce a little bit of the worlds car crashes, It also might have an effect with reducing stress on the person or on the Guardian's of that person. So that's why I think the ( Driving Age Should Be Raised )

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
1 point

Canadian researchers tried to untangle the influence of age and experience on crashes involving beginners by dividing drivers 16, 17, and 18 years old according to whether they had been driving less than a year or more than a year. The main finding, reported in 1992, is that 16 year-olds, especially girls this age, had higher rates of injury crashes than older teenagers who also were new to the road.

Supporting Evidence: A Life insurance finding (www.accuquote.com)
Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19esanders(26) Disputed
1 point

According to Alex Koroknay-Palicz, men are 77% more likely to be in a car accidents than women, does that mean we should only let women drive. Of course not, raising the driving age isn't taking away very much danger.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19asiebers(15) Disputed
1 point

As it said in the experiment, it was mostly teenage girls. but men are more likely to drive drunk. It's mostly teenagers because there are so many new influences and things to try. They are introduced to drugs,alcohol, and other adult things that they don't know how to use wisely.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
1 point

You may think it's an inconvenience, but it's better to

be safe than dead, or hurt. If you get hurt, it wastes more time.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19kremter(16) Disputed
0 points

You would just have to be careful on the road, a lot of teenagers are responsible and safe on the road. It doesn't matter about the age.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19tweinzetl(3) Disputed
1 point

Well how many teenagers are going to be very careful when there with there friends and your friends in the back seat are telling you stuff and handing a cigarette and beer. Then they will start daring you to do stuff then your so high out of your mind you don't know whats happening then... you drive off a bridge

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
0 points

I agree with Kayla. Why should all 16 year old be punished if only a couple of them are being irresponsible. We are putting labels on them without giving them a chance.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19asiebers(15) Disputed
0 points

But there are so many that aren't. I've seen at least one driving accident every week caused by teenagers. And that's just the NE. There is the rest of Wisconsin and the rest of the country!

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19esanders(26) Disputed
-1 points

Then, teenagers don't get to experience anything, or any responsibility.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19asiebers(15) Disputed
1 point

Things teenagers experience: Drugs, alcohol, drunk driving, distractions, and peer pressure. All of which, are experienced behind the wheel

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
1 point

If you make drivers ed earlier, 14 year olds are even more irresponsible.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19kremter(16) Disputed
1 point

I think they would be more responsible because they would have more experience

Side: No, don't raise driving age
1 point

My resources were those pages we got and I lost the other thing i got

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
1 point

On Dec. 29, 2005, four teenage boys from Chicago went out for a late-night drive and had a terrible accident.

Supporting Evidence: accident (teacher.scholastic.com)
Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
1 point

I think we should raise the driving age because many kids drink and drive. Drinking and driving is very common. Did you know that 32, 885 people died in 2010 in the USA. They died because of drinking and driving with traffic crashes. People will be more smart to know what drinking can do. This is why I believe we should raise the driving age.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
2 points

I think we should not raise the driving age because it teaches kids responsibility at an early age and gets them ready for the real world.

They say that there have been so many crashes but that is because the kids that crashed where not responsible just because those kids are not responsible doesn't mean all teens are not. If some do it don't punish all

Source: www.debate.org

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19tweinzetl(3) Disputed
2 points

Well kids at that age are very experimental. They like to try new things. Drugs drinking. They might think its funny to run a red light. Or be chased down by cops. And most of teenage crashes happen because they were the one who caused it.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19asiebers(15) Disputed
1 point

But there is so many teens that aren't responsible, it would be more reasonable to make everyone wait for their licence.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19blom Disputed
0 points

Well some teens simple can't wait teens are very busy and they need a car to get where they need to be also why should we make everyone wait when only some are not ready to get behind the wheel we shouldn't take away others privileges who are ready for the responsibility just because of the some in the past who where not ready.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
2 points

You should not raise the driving age. Raising the driving age is only punishing people that didn't do anything. "People get into more crashes at a young age"

is not always true. And if they raise the driving age for teenagers that are 16 because of that statement, they are punishing people who didn't get into crashes, for others mistakes.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19tweinzetl(3) Disputed
3 points

Did you know your are six times more likely to get in a car crash. And knowing teens they have all there friends texting them. Then they will get distracted and look at there phone and take there EYES OFF THE ROAD. And then who knows whats going to happen?

Supporting Evidence: Texting while driving (www.usnews.com)
Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19tstumpf(16) Disputed
2 points

I understand that people say it is a punishment to the kids to not have driving but I disagree. I disagree because there has been many deaths occurred by teenagers. If we raised the driving age it could be cut by a thousand deaths. Therefore we should raise the driving age

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
1 point

I agree! Just because some people have been irresponsible, doesn't mean everyone has.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19kremter(16) Clarified
1 point

I agree! people should give teenagers a chance to drive and not just let them go until they are like 20. Not everyone has gotten into a car crash, and a lot of 16,17, and 18 years old's are responsible.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
1 point

Source: Alex Koroknay-Palicz. Part of the National Youth Rights Association

Side: No, don't raise driving age
1 point

NO DONT RAISE THEM MORE CHILDREN WILL DIE IF YOU DOOOOOOO!

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19tstumpf(16) Disputed
1 point

How will teenagers die if you don't raise the driving age? Teenagers are not ready to get behind the wheel. They do not have the right education that they could get in driving class. They don't have the common sense to make on the road.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
0 points

I agree!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: No, don't raise driving age
1 point

i think that they shouldn't raise it because what if kids don't do drugs or drink then they will be trusted.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
1 point

No don't raise it lots of teenagers will be MAD if you do !!!!!

Side: No, don't raise driving age
1 point

It will make kids want to break the law because they should be able to drive at 16 not 18 so they will try to break the law and drive at 16

Side: No, don't raise driving age
1 point

Don't raise it because parents will be mad because they want there kids out of the house more and driving somewhere making experiences not sitting around the house because there parents don't want to drive them around so it would be good for parents to let kids drive at 16 its the way it is and the way it should stay!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: No, don't raise driving age
1 point

Yes kids tend to go to more parties when they are teenagers. But I disagree because during the parties there could be drinking. This leads to drinking and driving. This is just the smallest mistakes. Therefore the driving age should be raised.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
0 points

The driving age should not be raised. Many people think that teenagers are the reason there are more accidents, but that isn't true. Accidents are caused because of inexperience, not age. By raising the driving age it will just create more inexperience drivers because they will start learning something new at an older age. If we change to 18 there will be inexperienced 18 year olds.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19asiebers(15) Disputed
3 points

Although that may be true, I disagree. If you raise the driving age, teenagers will be more responsible, and more mature

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19blom Disputed
1 point

Lots of teens are already mature enough to get behind the wheel so why hold them back.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
0 points

I believe that the driving age should not be raised because parents are getting sick of driving their kids around when they get older. Your parents drove you around when you were little and when you get older you will want to go places with friends a lot more than you did when you were little, Your parents won't want to drive you around then.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19asiebers(15) Disputed
2 points

Would your parents rather drive you around, or not have you around at all? Parents would rather drive their kids around, then have them get in a accident and die.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19kremter(16) Clarified
2 points

This should have been a deleted comment,

but it wouldn't let me.

Side: Yes, raise the driving age.
19kremter(16) Disputed
1 point

If you were a teenager and you wanted to go to college or move out you wouldn't have a vehicle to get you around.

Side: No, don't raise driving age
19kremter(16) Disputed
1 point

Teenagers like to go out late at night or go to proms and dances. If i was a teenager i would be embarrassed to have my parents driving me around. Lets say that you were at a fire, at a friends house and you wanted to come home at 11 (like my brother does) your parents wouldn't want to get out of bed and come get you and bring you back home.

Side: No, don't raise driving age